21/06/2018
Share this story Share on Facebook icon Share on Twitter icon Share on Pinterest icon Share on Google Plus icon Share on Linked In icon Share via Email icon

The Battle of Bannockburn explained

685d04bc-8a30-42cd-bc65-cc84827b9156

The late Dr Alasdair Ross explains the background to the Battle of Bannockburn and the significance of the victory.

The battle of Bannockburn, fought over two days in June 1314, still holds significance for Scots 700 years later, for a number of reasons:

• The battle stands out in the pre-1707 history of Scotland as one of the few instances when the Scots won a decisive victory over a much larger invading army, and the only one when they did so in the open field.

• Bannockburn was also only the second time in European history that an army consisting of mostly infantry won victory over a mounted host; it was a victory against the odds which gave Scotland valuable breathing space and a new dynasty.

The battle was actually unwanted; until then, the Scots had avoided meeting the far larger and better equipped English armies in the open field and relied on guerrilla tactics for their successes. But we must never forget that since he knew an English army would try to relieve Stirling Castle in 1314, Bruce had a long time to prepare the ground of the battlefield beforehand.

Victory confirmed the rule of Robert I in Scotland (if not in London or Rome) and set the foundations for an invasion of Ireland, a mooted rebellion in Wales, and the Bruce and Stewart dynasties. Even though some Scots deserted to the English side on the night before the first day’s battle, to contemporaries a victory for Bruce must have meant that God was on his side. He was no longer a usurper.

Importantly, the battle of Bannockburn would remain present in the mind of Scots in the centuries that followed as an example of what could be done if people stood together; as proof that superior armies were not invincible, that ingenuity and tenacity could turn a seemingly hopeless situation into victory. For those reasons it is still annually commemorated and it has become part of Scottish national identity, an important defining moment in our national history.

Given all of this, it seems quite remarkable that even today we are still not quite sure about where all of the different elements of the battle were fought.

Battle of BannockburnCertain topographic markers, like the castle and the New Park, are known but the rest is fought over amongst commentators. Battlefield and war dead commemorations are relatively recent developments (at least in historical terms) and it is quite remarkable that by the time Archdeacon Barbour was writing The Brus in the 1370s, he felt confident enough to invent an entire extra division for the Scots army, led by the father of his patron, King Robert II.

Does this indicate that only sixty years after the great victory the majority of people had already forgotten the salient points about the battle order across the two days?


Why then should we be surprised that the precise locations of all of the different elements of the battle have also become lost?

 

Despite these minor difficulties, the battle of Bannockburn remains a matter of pride – and hope – to those with an interest in our nation’s history and future.

 

 

 

Back to "Expert history articles" Category

21/06/2018 Share this story   Share on Facebook icon Share on Twitter icon Share on Pinterest icon Share on Google Plus icon Share on Linked In icon Share via Email icon

Recent Updates

The QE2 passenger liner was launched - On this day in history

The QE2 passenger liner was launched on 20 September 1967. ...


Clan Carruthers has a chief confirmed by the Lord Lyon after 210 years

Clan Carruthers Society-International (CCSI) has announced that after a gap of 201 years, Clan Carruthers has ...


Painter William Dyce was born - On this day in history

Scottish painter William Dyce was born on 19 September 1806.


Historian Gilbert Burnet was born - On this day in history

Scottish historian Gilbert Burnet was born on 18 September 1643.


Other Articles

Precious David Linvingstone tableaux painstakingly restored as part of a £6.1M heritage project

A group of precious polychromatic plaster tableaux depicting David Livingstone's historic journey to Africa ...


David Dunbar Buick was born - On this day in history

Scottish inventor David Dunbar Buick was born on 17 September 1854.


On this day in Scottish history - King James VII of Scotland died

King James VII of Scotland died on 16 September 1701. ...


The Hector emigrant ship left Loch Broom bound for Canada

The Hector emigrant ship left Loch Broom bound for Canada on 15 September 1773.